Bundaberg club captain wins tram injury damages
BRISBANE, July 19.— A Bundaberg widow, Mrs. Henrietta Roberts (66), was awarded £923 damages against the Brisbane City Council today. She had asked for £2000 damages, claiming that she had been…
RISBANE, July 19.— A Bundaberg widow, Mrs. Henrietta Roberts (66), was awarded £923 damages against the Brisbane City Council today.
She had asked for £2000 damages, claiming that she had been injured getting out of an outbound Balmoral tram which suddenly moved forward. Costs were awarded by Judge Matthews against the council.
Mrs. Roberts said that before the accident she was an active woman and had been captain of the Bundaberg Croquet Club for 12 years. She had had to give up croquet and gardening.
Giving judgment, Mr. Justice Matthews said that one could not value the loss of playing croquet and of gardening.
Mrs. Roberts claimed that in February, 1950, she began to alight from a tram, but before she had done so completely the tram, through negligence, suddenly moved forward.
She said that she was thrown to the ground and suffered a fracture of the lumbar vertebra. This would result in permanent disability.
Evidence for the Council was that Mrs. Roberts put her right hand up to steady herself as she alighted. Her hand caught in the bell cord which rang the bell and the tram started to move.
Mr. L. L. Byth, for the council, argued that Mrs. Roberts accidentally gave what the motorman thought was a starting signal, two bells.
His Honour said that the public was entitled to protection against that sort of thing.
Mr. Byth: "Whatever she did, she may have caused the bell to ring twice. I ask your Honour to find no negligence by the tram crew.
Mr. B. O'Sullivan, for Mrs. Roberts, said that she had suffered serious injury. She would lose croquet and gardening recreations. It was hard to assess the loss of enjoyment, but it was a basis of damage.
His Honour said that he thought the tram proceeded without any action on Mrs. Roberts' part before she had properly alighted. He gave judgment for her with costs.

The article as it was printed in Maryborough Chronicle, 20 July 1951. Scan from Trove, National Library of Australia. (Trove, National Library of Australia)
Get HOOPLA! in your inbox
Topics



